What this button does
Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.
Multitasking feels productive, but it slows insurance agency work down and lets errors in. The brain can't run two demanding tasks at the same time. It switches between them, and each switch costs time and accuracy. For an account manager or CSR, that cost shows up as a wrong date on a certificate, a missed follow-up, or a renewal review that takes twice as long as it should.
For years, many agencies treated doing multiple things at once as a strength, and the busiest "multitaskers" were viewed as the most productive people in the office. The research points the other way, and the fix is less about effort than about how the day is set up.
What Is Multitasking, and Why Does Task Switching Slow Agency Work?
Multitasking means trying to handle more than one task in the same stretch of time. In an agency, it takes two forms. The first is doing two things at once, such as talking a client through a claim while typing an unrelated email. The second is jumping back and forth between open tasks all day.
Psychological research summarized by the American Psychological Association (APA) shows that people lose time whenever they move between tasks. The loss grows as the tasks get more complex or less familiar, according to the APA's summary of research on multitasking and switch costs. Experiments in this field usually compare reaction times and error rates when people repeat one task with the results when they alternate between two.
The APA describes two stages of executive control behind every switch. The first is goal shifting: deciding to do this now instead of that. The second is rule activation: turning off the rules for the old task and turning on the rules for the new one. Each stage of executive control takes only a fraction of a second, but the fractions add up over a day. Psychologist David Meyer, one of the researchers the APA cites, has estimated that these brief mental blocks can cost as much as 40 percent of a person's productive time. Treat that figure as an upper estimate, not a measurement of your agency. On an eight-hour day, 40 percent would be about 3.2 hours, so even a fraction of it deserves attention.
Is Anyone Able to Multitask? Human Multitasking and Brain Limits
For demanding work, the practical answer is no. Saying multitasking is a myth goes a bit too far, because people can pair an automatic activity, such as walking, with a demanding one. The trouble starts when two cognitive tasks need the same limited resource. That resource is usually working memory, the short-term space that holds what you are doing right now. Reviewing a commercial property schedule uses it, and so does answering a question about an auto claim. Together, the cognitive load exceeds what working memory can hold, so one task loses details.
Psychologists use terms such as executive function and cognitive control for the mental systems that keep goals in order and block distractions. Cognitive flexibility, the ability to move between sets of rules, is a real strength in service work, but using it every two minutes wears people down. You don't need a background in cognitive neuroscience or a theory of brain function to see the result at 4:00 p.m.
There is also a carryover effect. Researcher Sophie Leroy uses the term attention residue for the part of your attention that stays with the previous task after you move on. That matters in insurance, because agency staff are knowledge workers whose product is accurate thinking about coverage. A limit keyed incorrectly or a missed exclusion can become an errors-and-omissions claim against the agency.
Media Multitasking and Continuous Partial Attention at the Desk
The modern service desk makes the problem worse. Agency management systems sit on one monitor and email on the other, while a chat app pings and the phone rings. Using several screens and message streams at once is called media multitasking. Writer and consultant Linda Stone coined the second phrase in the heading above to describe the habit of always scanning for the next message, so no single task gets full attention.
The habit often grows out of good intentions, since nobody wants a client or carrier to wait. It can also stem from toxic productivity, a culture where looking busy and answering instantly count for more than finished, accurate work. If the fastest replier gets the praise, the team learns to keep every channel open.
The negative effects of multitasking in an agency are practical ones:
- Errors on a certificate of insurance or another outgoing document.
- Rework, because each interrupted task has to be re-read from the top.
- Mental fatigue, mental strain, and a shrinking attention span by mid-afternoon.
Over months, that kind of overload is one of the pressures behind job burnout.
Why No Account Manager Can Multitask Through a Renewal
Consider a hypothetical example. Dana is a commercial lines account manager who starts a renewal review for a contractor at 9:00. Her job is to compare the renewal quote with the expiring general liability policy, line by line. Within 20 minutes, she gets a certificate request by email, a chat message from a producer, and a call about a claim, and she answers each one right away.
Every time Dana returns to the renewal, she re-reads the last page to find her place. On the fourth return, she skips the page where the carrier changed the additional insured endorsement to a narrower form. Her task performance on each small request looked fine. The renewal review, the one job that needed deep work (sustained focus on one demanding task), is where quality dropped. The three tips below are built to prevent that morning.
Tip 1: Plan and Prioritize Instead of Relying on Multitasking Skills
Employees should start each day by reviewing current work and ranking it. A short plan ensures the most critical items get done first and aren't left until the last minute or left undone. Employees can enter, track, and prioritize much of this work in the agency management system or a separate work management platform. Make sure employees know how to review and update the system so they can move cleanly from one task to the next.
A written to-do list helps, too. Follow-ups and email dictate much of an employee's day, and a list reinforces what has to be finished today. It also gives stray thoughts a place to go: when an idea about another account pops up, the employee writes it down and returns to it later. At the end of the day, the list shows what was accomplished.
Tip 2: Use Time Tracking and Time Blocking to Limit Task Switching
Time is a finite resource. Three techniques help:
- Set a timer for tasks that should take a fixed amount of time, and stay on that task until the timer ends.
- Use time-tracking software for an objective measure of how long employees spend on individual tasks. DeskTime publishes a comparison of time-tracking software options.
- Use time blocking for larger tasks and appointments by giving them a set start and end time on the calendar. Batch email into blocks too, which cuts context switching between the inbox and everything else.
These techniques also show where additional training is needed, because a task that keeps running over its block is a signal. If the gap is time management itself, Total CSR's Career Development courses cover soft skills such as time management. For a wider view of operational efficiency, pair these steps with other ways to increase insurance agent productivity.
Tip 3: Organize the Workspace to Make Multitasking Harder
A cluttered workspace invites wandering attention, and that applies to both the physical desk and the technology on it.
- Keep the work area clear of paper and items the current task does not need.
- Build an inbox folder system and delete messages that are no longer needed.
- Turn off pop-up notifications during time blocks and close unused browser tabs.
Better attention allocation is the goal, not more effort. Shifting to one task at a time can be hard for committed multitaskers on your team. Start with one tip, try it for two weeks, and compare error rates and turnaround times before adding the next.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it possible to multitask on simple tasks?
Yes, when one task is close to automatic. Filing paper while listening to a voicemail usually works, because filing needs little thought. Two tasks that both require reading, writing, or judgment compete for the same mental resources, so both slow down and become less accurate. Policy checking, quoting, and client conversations belong in that second group.
Why does multitasking feel productive?
It feels productive because activity is easy to see and switch costs are not. Answering five messages in ten minutes produces visible results, while the renewal review that lost its focus shows no immediate damage. The cost appears later as rework or an error. Tracking how long core tasks take gives staff a more honest picture than the feeling of being busy.
How should CSRs handle phone calls that interrupt focused work?
Aim for a clean handoff, since calls are part of the job. Before picking up, the CSR writes one line on where the current task stopped and what comes next. After the call, they finish the call notes first, then return to that line. Some agencies also rotate phone coverage so each person gets one protected block per day.
How can a manager tell that multitasking is hurting the team?
Look for patterns, not single mistakes. Common signs include documents reissued for small errors, tasks reopened several times in the agency management system, and staff who were busy all day but finished nothing. Time-tracking data and a short conversation about daily interruptions will usually confirm what the error log suggests.
How long should a time block be?
There is no single correct length, so let the task decide. A certificate batch may need 30 minutes, while a complex renewal comparison may need 90. Tell coworkers when the block ends so clients and carriers are not left waiting. After a week or two, adjust based on how often the work was finished within the block.




