The 4 Traits of Top Performing Employees

The 4 traits of top-performing employees in an insurance agency, how to spot each one in an interview, and how to develop the people who have them.

By Trenton BerryPublished Updated
Four insurance employees of color around a table at work
Add to Preferred Sources

What this button does

Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.

The 4 traits of top performing employees in an insurance agency are critical thinking, flexibility, a desire to learn, and strong people skills. Experience may be desired, but it should not be the primary focus when you assess a potential hire.

The insurance job market has been competitive for years, and agencies of many sizes and locations feel pressure to bring in new talent. A job posting may draw several responses, yet not every applicant will be the right hire. Knowing which traits to look for gives your insurance agency hiring process a clear standard for each candidate.

What Makes a Great Employee: 4 Characteristics of Employees Who Excel

These four traits matter in every seat at an agency, from customer service to sales to management. None shows up on a resume, so each one below comes with the behavior that reveals it.

1. Critical thinking

People who can think "outside of the box" bring new ideas to the table. When problems come up, they look at them from different angles and produce creative solutions. In an agency, this trait often shows up as strategic thinking and commercial awareness, meaning an understanding of how the client's business makes money.

Here is a hypothetical example. An account manager notices that a contractor client has started renting out equipment, and she raises the exposure with the producer before renewal, not after a claim. Critical thinkers also tend to have a bias for action: they do something with what they notice. Many are comfortable in the role of respectful dissenter, the person who questions a process politely and then offers a better one.

2. Flexibility and adaptability

Much of insurance stays the same, but agencies often adopt new technology, revise processes, and change direction. Someone who is too rigid and resistant to change creates work for others and is less productive. Open-minded people who are prepared to adjust help move the agency closer to its goals. They tend to show resilience and a positive attitude when a carrier leaves a market, or a system conversion goes badly. They are also open to feedback.

3. A desire to learn

A willingness to always be a student of the industry is critical. Insurance carries an overwhelming amount of information, and client needs and carrier practices keep changing. A candidate who stays on top of new developments is an asset to the agency and its clients. Look for curiosity and a hunger to grow. Some managers call these people learning-obsessed. They treat lifelong learning as part of the job and ask for professional development opportunities without being prompted. Continuous learning also takes persistence.

4. High emotional intelligence

Every part of the insurance industry is relationship-driven: agency to carrier, employee to client, and employee to employee. People with this trait are empathetic and understanding, which lets them build strong relationships with clients and co-workers alike. In daily work, this trait shows up as active listening, proactive communication, and the social skills that support a collaborative work environment. It often comes with low ego. These employees share credit, admit mistakes early, and are honest and trustworthy with clients. Many employers overlook these abilities, as our article on the soft skills gap explains.

How to Spot a High-Potential Employee and Develop a Star Employee

Because resumes do not show these traits, the interview has to. Our list of insurance CSR interview questions is a useful starting point, and these four prompts map to the four traits:

  • Ask about a time the candidate disagreed with how something was done, and listen for the reasoning and the solution they proposed.
  • Ask about the last major change at work and how the candidate responded.
  • Ask what the candidate taught themselves in the past year, and why.
  • Ask about a difficult client conversation, and listen for accountability and for how well the candidate understood the other person's view.

Reference checks can confirm the basics that support all four traits: work ethic, time management, and initiative and drive. One common mistake is hiring on interview energy alone. Infectious enthusiasm and a competitive attitude are appealing, and both can help in a sales role. Neither one tells you how a person thinks, adapts, learns, or treats people, so score the four traits first.

Hiring is only the start. Employee potential turns into results when the agency invests in employee development. High-performing employees usually want three things from an employer:

  • Coaching and mentorship, plus meaningful feedback between formal performance reviews.
  • A path for career development, which career roadmapping can provide, with leadership training for people who show leadership skills.
  • Fair performance management, built on clear performance metrics and regular employee recognition.

Good talent management also protects the agency. When you know who has leadership qualities, succession planning becomes easier, and organizational performance depends less on one or two individuals.

As a next step, add the four traits to your interview scorecard and rate every candidate on each one. Product knowledge can be taught, while these traits often take far longer to develop.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should experience be the main factor when hiring for an insurance agency?

No. Experience is useful, but it should not be the primary focus. An experienced hire who resists change or handles relationships poorly can cost more than a newer person who thinks clearly and learns quickly.

Can these four traits be taught, or do you have to hire for them?

Both, in different degrees. Skills such as listening and organizing work improve with training and practice. A basic willingness to learn and to accept change is harder to build after the hire, so screen for it first.

Do the same traits apply to producers and to service staff?

Yes. Producers, account managers, and CSRs all solve problems, handle change, learn new coverages, and manage relationships. The mix differs by role, so adjust the interview questions to the job and keep the four traits constant.

How do you measure employee performance against these traits after the hire?

Tie each trait to behavior you can observe. For example, note whether an employee suggests process improvements and how they respond to a system change. Review those notes alongside production and service numbers.

How do agencies keep top performers from leaving?

Agencies keep top performers by giving them room to grow. People with these traits want to learn, so jobs with no new challenges tend to lose them. Regular feedback, a clear path to the next role, and recognition for good work all help.