The Soft Skills Gap: How Employers Are Missing Crucial Needs

Why CSRs and account managers often lack key soft skills, what the research found, and how agency leaders can hire for, train and measure them.

By Trenton BerryPublished Updated
Add to Preferred Sources

What this button does

Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.

Employers keep hiring for technical knowledge, then discover that new staff struggles with the human side of the job. In an insurance agency, that looks like a customer service representative who can process an endorsement but cannot calm an upset insured, or an account manager who knows the coverage but avoids hard renewal conversations. Closing the gap means hiring for soft skills on purpose, training them like any other subject, and measuring whether behavior changes.

What the Research Found About Skills Gaps in the Workplace

A 2018 press release from the Career Advisory Board, established by DeVry University, shared results of its 2018 Talent Activation, Employee Experience and Skills Development research. Anne Unger described "a gap in soft skills such as communications, business acumen and customer service." Employers in the survey said frontline workers were most affected: 71 percent of frontline employees lacked vital soft skills, compared with 63 percent at the supervisory level and 45 percent at the executive level.

The same survey found a blind spot. Respondents said they were "confident they are activating their talent," and more than 75 percent believed their development programs gave employees the tools to grow. The gaps they reported suggest those programs were not reaching the behaviors that matter most. The skill areas named in the research were:

  • Digital fluency
  • Communication
  • Business acumen
  • Cultural awareness
  • Customer service

Where the Skill Gap Shows Up in an Insurance Agency

Agencies feel this most in client-facing seats, where a single call can decide a renewal. CSRs and account managers need technical skills, such as reading a declarations page, but the job also runs on interpersonal skills. When those skills are weak, the cost is concrete: slower service, more escalations to the owner, more errors and omissions exposure from unclear notes, and lower productivity. The table below links common agency moments to the soft skill each one tests.

Agency moment Soft skill being tested
A client calls angry about a premium increase Empathy and emotional intelligence
Two renewals and a certificate request land at once Time management
A coverage question has no clear answer in the policy Critical thinking and problem-solving
A producer and a CSR disagree on who owns a task Conflict resolution and teamwork
A carrier changes its portal or underwriting appetite Adaptability and digital skills
A client needs a coverage gap explained in writing Business writing skills

Spotting a Lack of Skills Before You Hire

Skills-based hiring tests what a candidate can do rather than relying on formal education or past job titles. Many agencies hire career changers and recent graduates with no insurance background. Their people skills, especially interpersonal communication, often best predict how they will handle clients once they learn the coverage. Use structured, behavioral interview questions for CSRs that ask for a specific past example. Ask candidates to describe a time they handled a frustrated customer, managed competing deadlines, or admitted a mistake. Listen for self-awareness and personal responsibility, two of the emotional competencies that show up in client work. A short role-play of a difficult call often reveals more than a résumé does.

Training Soft Skills Like Any Other Subject

Soft skills improve with practice, not with one seminar. Treat them as part of learning and development, alongside coverage and system training. Role-plays and call reviews are experiential learning, and they stick better than lectures. Managers need the same training. A supervisor who cannot run a coaching conversation will struggle to build any of these habits in a team. Total CSR's Career Development program includes soft skills courses for both employees and managers.

A practical plan for upskilling current staff and reskilling new hires:

  1. Pick two or three behaviors to improve first, such as call de-escalation.
  2. Use on-the-job learning: review real calls and emails each week.
  3. Use mentoring for peer-to-peer learning and knowledge transfer.
  4. Practice presentation skills and public speaking skills before renewal meetings.
  5. Give specific feedback on behavior, not personality.

Measuring Whether Training Works

Set a baseline before training starts so you can see change. Useful measures include client complaint counts, calls escalated to a manager, renewal retention on each book, and quality scores from call or email reviews. Recheck them each quarter.

Why Soft Skills Protect Your Team

Soft skills also protect your staff. CSRs who can set boundaries with demanding clients and use healthy coping strategies show more resilience and are less likely to reach burnout. That supports employee engagement, a stronger workplace culture, and better employee retention, which ties these essential soft skills directly to business performance.

Start this week: pick one client-facing behavior, measure it, and review it weekly.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a skills gap in an insurance agency?

A skills gap is the difference between the skills a role requires and the skills the person in it actually has. In an agency, it can be technical (such as not knowing how to read a policy form) or behavioral, such as struggling to explain a coverage limitation to a client. Soft-skills gaps are harder to see because they don't show up on a licensing exam.

Which soft skills matter most for CSRs and account managers?

Clear, professional communication; listening; patience with stressed clients; organization under deadline pressure; and sound judgment matter most. These people handle claims questions, renewals, and service requests all day, so their tone and accuracy shape how clients view the agency. Collaboration and relationship-building with producers and carriers matter too, because most service work passes through several hands before it is finished.

Can soft skills really be taught, or are they personality traits?

Yes, soft skills are professional skills that can be taught, although some people start with stronger natural habits. Behaviors such as summarizing a client's concern before answering, confirming next steps in writing, or pausing before replying to an angry email are learnable routines. Repetition with real examples and regular manager review work far better than a single workshop, and they build habits that support long-term professional success.

How do soft skills affect errors and omissions risk?

Weak communication is a common thread in errors and omissions (E&O) claims against agencies. A CSR who does not confirm a coverage request in writing, or who fails to explain an exclusion clearly, creates a record that may not support the agency later. Good self-regulation under pressure, careful note-taking, and clear decision-making help reduce that exposure, alongside the agency's own documentation procedures.

How long does it take to build soft skills across a team?

There is no fixed timeline because it depends on the skill, the employee, and how often they practice. Agencies that review real client interactions weekly usually see changes in specific behaviors within a few months. Track a small set of measures, such as escalations and complaint counts, so you can tell whether training is working and adjust it as needed. Creative, innovative coaching also helps keep staff engaged.