Quick Tips for Tackling Conflict in the Office: How to Have Difficult Conversations at Work

How to handle conflict between agency coworkers: prepare, find the root cause, listen well, agree on next steps, and know when behavior has turned toxic.

By Trenton BerryPublished Updated
Woman standing in front of coworkers at insurance agency
Add to Preferred Sources

What this button does

Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.

Conflict between coworkers in an insurance agency rarely fixes itself. The fastest way through it is a planned, private talk: name the specific behavior, hear each person's side, find the cause, and agree on what changes next. Handled early, that talk keeps a disagreement between an account manager and a producer from becoming a team problem.

Every person on an agency staff is wired differently. That mix helps when CSRs, account managers, and producers play off each other's strengths, but contrasting temperaments can also create friction that disrupts service and work. Employees do not need to be best friends. They do need enough decency and respect to work together without being miserable.

Prepare for Tough Conversations Before You Talk

Many of these talks go wrong before anyone speaks, because the manager walks in angry, rushed, or already sure of the answer. Start with self-reflection: what do you actually know, what are you assuming, and what outcome would be fair to both people? Self-management matters too. If a missed renewal or a heated email still has you upset, wait until you can stay calm and save your emotional energy for listening.

Then plan the setting. Pick a private room or a scheduled call, not the open office or a group chat. Write down one or two specific examples with dates so the discussion stays on facts. Try putting yourself in their shoes first: a CSR who keeps missing producer requests may be buried in endorsements nobody else sees.

Preparing also means remembering that different agency roles call for different strengths. A producer's drive to close and a CSR's attention to policy detail can look like opposing priorities, and in conflict, two people may start to dismiss each other's role. When that happens, step back and look at how every position helps the agency serve clients and grow.

Then pull the focus back to shared goals, such as keeping a large commercial account or finishing renewal season on time. Naming what both people need creates common ground and reminds everyone that organizational success depends on each of them. Specific positive feedback about what each person does well also lowers defensive responses before the harder part of the talk.

How to Discuss the Root Cause, Not Just the Symptoms

Workplace conflict is rarely what it seems on the surface. One employee may lack training while a coworker feels burdened covering the gaps. Two people may have misaligned expectations about who owns a task. Sometimes faulty communication triggers it, and sometimes personality types clash. Left unaddressed, or addressed the wrong way, resentment builds quickly.

Open dialogue with each person is how you find the real cause. Ask open-ended questions such as "Walk me through what happened on that renewal" instead of "Why did you miss the deadline?" Practice active listening by summarizing what you heard and asking whether you got it right. Empathetic listening also means recognizing emotions without judging them and watching body language, yours and theirs.

It also helps to describe the problem the way a neutral observer would, an approach sometimes called the "third story." In a hypothetical example, instead of "You keep dumping work on me," the manager says, "Service requests are reaching Maria after 4 p.m., and she is staying late to finish them." That framing helps you avoid judgments, keeps each point of view on the table, and can surface hidden purposes, such as a producer who sends requests late because carriers answer late.

Once you know the cause, match the fix to it. Additional training can close a skill gap, and Total CSR's Career Development courses cover soft skills such as feedback, conflict, and communication. Clearer handoff rules fix misaligned expectations. For clashing personalities, consider having both employees complete a personality profile such as the Enneagram, which gives each person insight into how they think, process, and respond.

Turn Challenging Conversations Into a Constructive Conversation

These talks become productive conversations when they end with agreement on specific next steps. Restate what each person will do differently, set boundaries on behavior that must stop, and schedule a short follow-up. Constructive feedback works best when it names behavior and impact, not personality. A human-centered approach maintains accountability while treating both people as capable adults.

Pay attention to cultural differences, too. Teams with diverse perspectives may differ in how directly people disagree, so cross-cultural communication can mean asking how someone prefers to receive feedback. Non-defensive communication from the manager, such as admitting where unclear instructions contributed, makes it easier for employees to do the same.

Over time, these crucial conversations shape team dynamics and organizational culture. When raising a problem leads to a fair process, employees gain the psychological safety to speak up early. Strong communication skills in leadership also support employee satisfaction, because people want to work where they feel heard.

When Conflict Becomes Toxic Behavior

Conflict is one thing; toxic behavior is more serious. Whatever skills an employee brings, it is not worth letting them create a toxic environment. Tolerating it can drive down morale, erode agency culture, and push good employees toward a workplace where they feel cared for and valued. Patterns like gossip that keep gaining steam are worth addressing early. Some difficult people will not change after a fair process. If an employee stays divisive and refuses to change, document the conversations and have a termination plan that follows your agency's policies.

Disagreements between employees are inevitable, but they do not have to be disastrous. Applying these communication principles consistently builds mutual understanding and effective communication. The conversation skills managers develop along the way turn conflict resolution into a way to build stronger teams. For more, listen to the full episode of The Independent Agent on what to do when processes and personalities don't mix.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who should lead difficult conversations between two employees?

The person who manages both employees should usually lead, because they can set expectations and follow up. In a small agency, that may be the owner. If the manager is part of the conflict, another leader should step in so both employees see the process as fair.

Should a manager meet with both employees together or separately?

Start separately. Private meetings let each person explain their side without performing for the other. Once you understand the cause, a joint meeting can confirm the agreement, clarify handoffs, and set a follow-up date so both people hear the same expectations.

What if an employee gets angry or shuts down during the talk?

Pause instead of pushing ahead. Acknowledge the reaction, offer a short break, and come back to the specific example. If emotions stay high, reschedule within a day or two so the issue does not drift. Calm, consistent follow-through usually matters more than getting everything resolved in one meeting.

When should a manager bring in HR or outside help?

Bring in HR or legal guidance when the conflict involves sensitive topics such as harassment, discrimination, threats, or possible policy violations. Those situations may carry legal duties to investigate and document. Follow your agency's written policies, and do not try to settle them as an ordinary personality clash.

How is conflict with clients different from conflict between coworkers?

With clients, the account manager is protecting a relationship and a book of business rather than mediating between peers. The goal is to calm the situation, solve the coverage or service issue, and document it. Total CSR covers that situation in 4 steps account managers can take to handle difficult clients, which pairs well with the coworker approach here.