What this button does
Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.
A trial period (often called a probationary period) is a set stretch at the start of a job when an agency trains a new hire, measures progress and decides whether to continue. Used well, it gives both sides an early, honest answer.
A new account manager or CSR touches client policies quickly, so an agency needs to know early whether the person is right for the job and a good fit for the company.
Probationary periods are not a legal shortcut, though, and the real work is deciding well before the end of the probationary period.
What Is a Probationary Period?
A new hire probationary period is a company policy, not a legal status. It usually starts on the date of hire. Many employers use 90 days, and some use three to six months.
You may also see it called a probation period, an introductory period or probationary employment. Some employers avoid the word because it carries a negative connotation for job seekers, and they worry that a negative stigma will narrow their talent pool.
Whatever the name, the purpose is to evaluate an employee against the job duties, skills, and qualifications you hired for, as well as your company policies. At the same time, the person decides whether the new position suits them.
What a Probationary Period Does Not Change Legally
In most states, the default is at-will employment: either side may terminate employment at any time, with or without cause, unless a contract or law says otherwise. An at-will employer has that right before, during, and after probation.
So a probationary period adds no new right to fire, and workplace protections apply from the first day of work. Federal laws enforced by the EEOC bar covered employers from basing decisions on protected characteristics such as race, sex, religion, age, and disability. Those anti-discrimination laws make no exception for probation.
State employment laws can go further. California's Fair Employment and Housing Act, for example, applies to employers with five or more employees and protects applicants as well as employees. A firing during probation can still lead to wrongful termination lawsuits or other legal action.
Calling someone a "permanent employee" after probation, or promising to fire only for just cause or good cause, can weaken your at-will position. An employment contract, a collective bargaining agreement, other contractual agreements, written policies, and even past practices can create similar obligations.
Probationary periods also do not control employee benefits. Under the Affordable Care Act, a group health plan must not apply a waiting period that exceeds 90 days for health insurance. Waiting periods for disability insurance, paid time off, vacation time, and sick leave depend on plan terms and on state or local law.
Under the Family and Medical Leave Act, eligibility requires 12 months of employment with a covered employer and 1,250 hours of service. State law determines who qualifies for unemployment benefits, and a probationary label does not change a worker's employment status.
Some employers pay a lower wage or delay benefits to trim benefits costs. Minimum wage rules still apply, and uneven application invites claims of unfair treatment. Have legal counsel review your employee handbook. An agency with no legal team can use outside counsel.
How to Run a 90-Day Probationary Period
In a 2019 Forbes article, eight members of the Young Entrepreneur Council shared their top tips for designing effective trial periods. The best practices below apply their ideas to agency work.
Start before the offer. Hiring new employees is expensive, and losing them early costs more. Treat the interview process as the first step of onboarding: write accurate job descriptions, use behavioral-based questions and reference checks, and share your values. A hiring process that shows candidates what to expect when they start prevents surprises later.
Use a 30-60-90 day plan. Set goals and objectives for each 30 days, with daily tasks, performance indicators, and expected results. In a hypothetical plan, a commercial lines CSR finishes core coursework by day 30, issues certificates under review by day 60, and processes endorsements alone by day 90.
Pair the new hire with an experienced employee. Shadowing lets new hires ask questions and learn how the agency really works. Meet regularly with the mentor to discuss the new hire's progress, and back up shadowing with structured employee training.
Make information easy to find. A key suggestion from Derek Robinson in that article is a well-organized knowledge base. New hires can then look up what they need without being flooded.
Bring new employees into the culture early. Invite them to team meetings and agency events from week one. People who feel like a valued part of the team tend to trust the agency more, which supports job satisfaction, employee morale, and, over time, retention rates.
Check in every week. Short weekly check-ins on job performance let you praise progress, catch underperformance early, and document both. Clear expectations give new talent a fair chance to do their best. The aim is increased productivity and increased motivation, not a surprise at day 90.
Treat probation as part of your onboarding process, not as a separate test. Managers should evaluate employees against the written plan.
Extending the Probationary Period or Ending It
Schedule a formal performance evaluation about two weeks before the last day. You are deciding if the employee has met the plan, so act before the period ends.
If the person did complete the plan, confirm it in writing. If the person is close but missed training time, an extension can be fair. Put the new end date and goals in writing.
If the fit is not there, treat the decision like any other employee termination. Review the documentation, confirm that similar new employees were treated the same way, and check that earlier feedback or disciplinary action matches the reason you give.
The same advice helps your commercial clients. Claims by fired workers are what employment practices liability insurance is designed to address, so careful probationary periods protect your insureds and your agency.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long should an employee probationary period last?
No federal law sets one length for private employers. Ninety days is common, and longer probationary periods can suit technical roles. Match the length to your training plan and state it in the offer letter.
Can you fire someone during a probationary period without a reason?
In most states, at-will rules allow it, during the probationary period or after. The reason cannot be illegal, such as discrimination or retaliation, and a contract or union agreement may require more. Check with employment counsel first.
Do new hires get benefits during a probationary period?
Group health coverage cannot make an eligible employee wait more than 90 days, while other benefits follow each plan's terms and any state or local leave rules.
Does passing a probationary period guarantee the job?
No, unless you promise that it does. In an at-will relationship, completing it does not create a contract for continued work. Avoid handbook phrases suggesting a person can be fired only for specific reasons.
Should an agency call it a probationary period at all?
That is your choice, because the label has little legal effect. What matters is that probationary periods include a written plan, regular feedback, and a clear decision date.




