16 min read

The CCAT and Cognitive Aptitude Tests: Are They Worth It for Agencies?

What the CCAT test measures, how scoring works, what the research and the EEOC say, and how an insurance agency should use an aptitude test when hiring.

By Justin Goodman, Co-Founder and CEO, Total CSRPublished
Cartoon businessman holding a stopwatch and pointing at a laptop that shows a timed reasoning puzzle
Add to Preferred Sources

What this button does

Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.

For most independent agencies, the CCAT test is worth using only in a limited way. It gives you one job-related data point about how quickly a candidate reasons and learns, which matters in roles that demand fast learning and accuracy. It earns its place when every candidate for a role takes it at the same stage, and when you weigh the result alongside structured interviews and an insurance knowledge check. It is not worth it as a stand-alone pass or fail gate, and a small agency has to watch both the cost and the risk of adverse impact.

Almost everything written about this test targets candidates who want a higher result. This guide covers the same ground from the employer's chair: what a candidate faces in those 15 minutes, what the research and the law say, and how to read a result for each agency role.

What Is the CCAT Test?

The CCAT is a short, timed general reasoning test that employers give to job candidates. It is a psychometric test, meaning a standardized measure with fixed instructions, timing, and scoring. It is a different product from the Canadian Cognitive Abilities Test, which schools use with children.

What the Criteria Cognitive Aptitude Test Measures

According to the publisher's CCAT overview page, the test measures critical thinking, problem solving, learning ability, and the ability to digest and apply new information. The publisher's CCAT information brief says it is commonly used for mid- to high-level positions and for jobs that involve a great deal of training. That second use is the one that matters to an agency, because a new CSR has to absorb coverage forms, carrier rules, and system steps quickly.

Who Publishes the Test

Criteria Corp, which some sites write as Criteria Corporation, publishes the test and offers it to employers through its testing platform. Naming the publisher is not an endorsement. Other vendors sell similar timed reasoning tests, and the points in this article apply to any of them.

Where a CCAT Assessment Fits in Hiring

A sensible place for any pre-employment assessment is after the resume screen and before final interviews. Wherever it sits in your agency hiring process, the stage must be the same for every applicant to that role. Giving a test only to candidates a manager doubts is unfair and hard to defend.

Inside the Test: Format and Candidate Experience

50 Questions in 15 Minutes

The test has 50 multiple-choice items and a strict time limit, which works out to less than 20 seconds per item. Criteria's candidate preparation page says fewer than 1% of candidates answer all 50 questions, and the publisher's help center article on the CCAT says that not finishing is by design. Under those time constraints, a candidate who leaves many items blank has not failed. An unfinished test is the normal outcome.

No Calculator, and a Word on Pen and Paper

The candidate preparation page states that no calculators are allowed and that no item requires one, so candidates rely on mental math and estimation. The publisher's public pages reviewed for this article do not say whether scratch paper is permitted. Settle that point with your vendor, then give every candidate the same rule in the invitation email.

Guessing and Negative Marking

Candidates lose nothing for a miss. The candidate preparation page says there is no penalty for wrong answers, and it advises test takers to guess and move on when an item has taken more than a minute. Time management therefore shapes the result.

Taken Online, Usually Unsupervised

The information brief describes an online assessment that runs on a phone, tablet, laptop, or desktop and can be completed remotely without supervision. The publisher acknowledges that an unsupervised candidate could have help. Its safeguards include an item bank of thousands of items and detailed session logs. If a remote result sits far above what you see in the interview, ask the vendor about a second, supervised sitting, and apply the same policy to everyone.

The Three Question Types

The information brief names three abilities: spatial reasoning, verbal ability, and math and logic. Prep sites usually relabel them as verbal reasoning, numerical reasoning, and spatial or abstract reasoning. Knowing the three question types helps a hiring manager judge how closely each one matches the job.

Verbal Reasoning

The publisher calls this area verbal ability. It covers reading comprehension, logic, constructive thinking, and attention to detail, tested through sentence completion, vocabulary, and word comparison items. For an agency, verbal reasoning most closely matches daily work: reading policy language, following written procedures, and writing clear emails to insureds.

Math and Logic, or Numerical Reasoning

This area measures the ability to reason with numbers and numerical concepts, along with logic and analytical thinking. The candidate preparation page lists basic algebra, proportions, and word problems. The arithmetic is simple, and the pressure comes from the clock. Agency staff do comparable work when they prorate a premium or check a rating basis.

Spatial Reasoning

Spatial reasoning is the ability to visualize objects in physical space, make spatial judgments, and solve problems that involve shapes and patterns. Other test publishers describe similar content as abstract reasoning or pattern recognition. This area has the least obvious link to insurance work, which is one reason to rely on the overall result rather than a single sub-area.

Item Styles a Job Aptitude Test Often Uses

Criteria does not publish a full list of item styles. The labels below are ones candidates meet in preparation material for timed reasoning tests in general. They give you a working vocabulary when a candidate asks what was on the test, but they are not an official blueprint of the CCAT.

Antonyms, Word Analogy and Sentence Completion

Antonyms ask for the opposite of a given word, and this is the style the publisher uses as its public verbal sample. An analogy item gives one pair of words and asks for a second pair with the same relationship. A completion item asks which word or words best fill a blank in a sentence. All three depend on vocabulary and careful reading, not on insurance knowledge.

Syllogisms and Logical Reasoning

A syllogism gives two statements and asks whether a conclusion must follow. A simple illustration: every binder is temporary; this document is a binder, so this document is temporary. Logical reasoning items test whether a person can separate what is stated from what is only likely.

Number Series, Arithmetic Mean and Percentage Calculation

A number series shows a sequence and asks for the next value. An arithmetic mean item is an average problem, like the publisher's public sample: three numbers average 17, two of them are 12 and 19, so the third must be 20. Other common styles ask for a percentage of an amount, or ask which fraction value in a list is the largest. The math is basic, but each item must be solved in seconds.

Odd One Out, Matrix Questions and Shape Series

An odd one out item shows several figures and asks which one does not belong; the publisher's public spatial sample is of this kind. A matrix item shows a grid of figures with one cell missing. A shape series shows figures that change step by step and asks what comes next.

How Scoring Works

Raw Score and Percentile Score

Each candidate receives a raw score, which is the number of correct answers out of 50, and a percentile ranking against the publisher's norm group. A percentile of 45 means the person did better than 45% of that group. The report also gives a separate percentile for each of the three abilities.

The Average Score

Criteria tells candidates that the average test taker gets 24 items right, and the information brief reports a median of 24 in a normative sample of 106,740 adults. A candidate who answers about half of the items correctly is therefore typical, not weak. Hiring managers who expect school-style results of 80% or 90% need to hear this before they open their first report.

What a CCAT Score Report Shows

The employer's report compares the candidate's result with suggested ranges for dozens of job families. In the sample shown in the information brief, the suggested range is 17 to 50 for Customer Service Representative and for Sales Representative, and 19 to 50 for Sales / Account Executive. Criteria says the ranges are based on large samples of prior results, and that employers can build their own. The published list has no insurance-specific job family, so an agency has to choose the closest match.

Why a Single Passing Score Is a Mistake

The suggested ranges are wide, and they start below the median. The publisher frames a result as inside or outside a range, not as a pass or a fail. An agency that invents a hard cut, such as rejecting everyone under 30, turns away most typical candidates without evidence that the cut predicts success in its own jobs. If you set a floor at all, start from the suggested range for the closest job family.

Does a Cognitive Ability Test Predict Job Performance?

Yes, to a degree, and less than older research suggested.

The Older View: General Mental Ability on Top

For decades, industrial psychologists rated general mental ability as the strongest single predictor of job performance. A 2023 review by Sackett and colleagues records that the corrected validity of general mental ability was previously believed to be .51. Claims that a short reasoning test outperforms most other hiring tools trace back to that body of work.

The 2022 Re-Analysis

In 2022, Paul Sackett and his coauthors re-examined how earlier studies had corrected their statistics and concluded that many validity estimates were too high. According to the 2023 review, the revised estimate for general mental ability is .31, and structured interviews top the list with a mean validity of .42. They conclude that it deserves a reduced role in typical hiring, while it still merits consideration for jobs with lengthy, expensive training.

What the Publisher Reports

Criteria's information brief cites the company's own studies. In one of them, results on the test correlated .33 with performance during a training period in a sample of 745 sales representatives. That is a real relationship, but it is far from a guarantee about any one person, and it comes from sales jobs in general, not from insurance agencies.

What Candidates Find Online Before Test Day

Nearly every search result for this test is written for candidates.

Free CCAT Practice Test Sites

Criteria's candidate preparation page links to free practice tests of its own, and many independent sites offer a practice test built to resemble the real one. The independent versions vary in quality and are not written by the publisher. A candidate who has tried one already knows the pace and the three question types before the real attempt, which removes a source of surprise.

CCAT Practice Questions From the Publisher

The official candidate page shows one sample item for each of the three areas, with the answer and an explanation. It also gives short advice: read the instructions fully, limit the time spent on any one item, and take the test somewhere free of distractions. Because this material is free and official, it is the safest thing to point candidates toward.

The Free CCAT Mock Test Problem

Full-length timed simulations give some candidates several rehearsals of the format. A candidate who has rehearsed will manage the clock better than one who sees the format cold, so the gap between their results reflects preparation as well as ability. That is one more reason not to treat small differences between candidates as meaningful.

Does the Best CCAT Prep Change the Result?

Paid options exist as well. A prep course typically bundles timed practice drills, interactive practice, and solving strategies for each item style. Some sites add a score calculator that estimates a percentile without the publisher's norm group. Preparation mostly helps a candidate reach their score potential by removing surprise and wasted time. For competitive roles with many applicants, assume that some candidates have prepared and others have not.

Send Every Candidate the Same CCAT Sample Test

The fair response is to level the field. In the invitation, send every candidate the same link to the publisher's free candidate guide and practice resources, describe the format, and state your rule on scratch paper. This step costs nothing, and it makes results easier to compare.

What a Free CCAT Test Sample Teaches a Hiring Manager

Try the sample items yourself before you ask candidates to take the test. A few minutes shows a hiring manager how the clock feels and how little the content resembles insurance work. The CCAT test tips written for candidates teach the same lesson: the advice is about pace and guessing, not knowledge.

Legal Points for US Employers

This section is general information, not legal advice. Review any testing program with employment counsel before you start, including the state and local rules that apply to your agency.

Job Related and Consistent With Business Necessity

The EEOC's fact sheet on employment tests and selection procedures says a neutral test that disproportionately excludes a protected group is unlawful under Title VII unless the employer can show it is job-related and consistent with business necessity. It adds that a vendor's validity documentation may help, but the employer is still responsible for ensuring its tests are valid. For an agency, that means documenting why fast learning and sound reasoning matter in the specific role before testing the first candidate.

Adverse Impact and the Four-Fifths Rule

Adverse impact means a substantially different rate of selection for one group. The EEOC's questions and answers on the Uniform Guidelines describe the four-fifths rule: a selection rate for one group that is less than 80% of the rate for the highest group is generally regarded as substantially different. The agencies call the rule a practical means of focusing attention, not a legal definition. A hypothetical illustration: 10 of 20 applicants in one group clear your floor (50%), and 3 of 10 in another group do (30%). The ratio is 60%, which is below four-fifths.

Reasonable Accommodation Under the ADA

The fact sheet says employers must make reasonable accommodations when administering tests for qualified applicants with disabilities, unless doing so would cause undue hardship. A strictly timed, screen-based test can put a candidate with a learning disability or a visual impairment at a disadvantage for reasons unrelated to the job. Tell every candidate how to request an accommodation before the test, and ask the vendor which options it supports.

Consistent Use and Record Keeping

Give the same test, at the same stage, with the same instructions, to every candidate for a role. Do not adjust results or use different cutoffs by group, which the fact sheet says Title VII prohibits. The EEOC's recordkeeping requirements page says employers must keep all personnel or employment records for one year, and until final disposition once a charge is filed. Keep each candidate's result, the range you applied, and the reason for the decision.

How an Agency Should Use the Scores

Treat the result as one input among several, weighted by role.

Customer Service Representatives

A new customer service representative has to learn forms, carrier systems, and procedures in the first months, so learning speed is relevant. Keep in mind that a timed reasoning test rewards fast response times, while careful service work often rewards slowing down. The result is most useful for setting the training pace in your new hire onboarding checklist.

Account Managers

An account manager handles renewals, coverage comparisons, and client questions with less supervision. Reasoning and reading skills matter, but so do insurance knowledge and judgment, which the test does not measure. For an experienced hire, a coverage knowledge check will tell you more than a reasoning percentile.

Producers

For a producer, drive, resilience, and prospecting habits weigh heavily, and a reasoning test measures none of them. The publisher's sales training study suggests the result says something about how quickly a new producer will learn products. Pair it with a structured interview and, if you use them, sales personality tests for insurance hiring.

A Hypothetical Example

This example is illustrative only. An agency is hiring a commercial lines CSR and tests three finalists, who answer 19, 27, and 38 items correctly. All three fall inside the publisher's suggested range of 17 to 50 for customer service representatives, so none is screened out. In structured interviews and a short work sample (checking a certificate request against a policy summary), the candidate with 27 performs best and is hired. The test informed the decision without making it.

Cost and Effort for a Small Agency

Assessment vendors generally sell employer testing by subscription or by quote, so ask for written pricing based on the number of candidates you expect to test. An agency that hires two or three people a year may pay for capacity it never uses. Weigh that cost against the high costs of turnover when a hire fails.

The higher cost is staff time. Someone has to document why the test is job-related, send invitations, handle accommodation requests, read the reports correctly, and keep the records. If nobody owns those tasks, the test will be used inconsistently, which is worse than not testing at all.

Alternatives and Complements

Structured Interviews

A structured interview asks every candidate the same job-related questions and rates the answers against a set standard. In the Sackett review, structured interviews rank above tests of general mental ability. They cost only preparation time, which suits a small agency. A bank of insurance CSR interview questions is a practical place to start.

Work Samples

A work sample asks the candidate to do a small piece of the real job, such as reviewing a policy change request. The Sackett authors list work sample tests among the job-specific predictors with the highest validity. A paid new hire trial period extends the same idea past the offer.

Insurance Knowledge and Skills Assessments

For experienced candidates, test what the job requires, and match the difficulty level to the role. Total CSR, an insurance agency training and development platform, offers pre-hire and employee assessments that rate candidates on emotional intelligence, personality fit, aptitude, computer skills, and insurance knowledge, and can generate interview questions. Whichever tool you choose, the legal standards described above still apply.

Personality Tools

Personality questionnaires describe work style and preferences, not ability. They can add context for sales and service roles, especially when they prompt better interview questions. The same rules on job relatedness, consistency, and accommodation apply.

A Decision Checklist for Agencies

Work through these steps before you buy any reasoning test. Taking the time fits the principle of hiring slowly.

  1. Write down, role by role, why learning speed and reasoning matter to the job.
  2. Fix the stage at which every candidate for that role will be tested.
  3. Choose a range, not a single cut, starting from the closest suggested job family.
  4. Send all candidates the same preparation link and the same description of the format.
  5. Tell candidates how to request an accommodation.
  6. Combine the result with a structured interview, a work sample, and a knowledge check.
  7. Keep records, and review results with employment counsel each year.

If you cannot commit to those steps, skip the test and put the effort into better interviews. If you can, the CCAT or a similar test can add a useful, limited signal to a decision that still rests on your own judgment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Criteria Cognitive Aptitude Test Result Enough to Reject a Candidate?

No, a result on its own is a weak basis for rejection. The publisher reports results against wide suggested ranges, not a pass mark, and a typical candidate answers about half of the items correctly. Combine the result with a structured interview, a work sample, and an insurance knowledge check, and document the job-related reason for any floor you set.

What Is the Crossover Cognitive Aptitude Test?

It is the CCAT, as one employer, Crossover, uses it for its own applicants. Crossover's support page on the CCAT says the test is required when applying to work with Crossover, and that a candidate may attempt it only once per email address in six months. The example shows that each employer sets its own rules around a published test. An agency should write its own rules down as well.

Should a Small Agency Test Candidates for Every Role?

Usually not. A reasoning test is most defensible where the role demands fast learning, such as a trainee CSR or a new producer with no insurance background. For an experienced account manager, insurance knowledge and work history carry more information. Whatever you decide, apply it by role: every candidate for the same job gets the same test at the same stage.

Can Candidates Improve Their Results With Practice?

Practice helps with pace and familiarity. The publisher itself gives candidates free sample items and advice on guessing and timing, so knowing the format has value. An employer cannot see how much a candidate rehearsed. The practical answer is to send every candidate the same official preparation link and to avoid reading meaning into small differences between results.

What Should an Agency Tell Candidates Before the Test?

Tell them the format, the rules, and how the result will be used. A fair invitation states the number of items and the time allowed, says that calculators are not permitted, explains that most people do not finish, and links to the publisher's free preparation page. It should also say how to request an accommodation and make clear that the result is one factor alongside interviews and other checks.