Dealing with a Top Producer Driving Account Managers Away

A high-revenue producer keeps costing your agency account managers. Learn how to confirm the cause, hold the conversation, and decide what comes next.

By Trenton BerryPublished Updated
Three insurance workers discussing conflict with producer
Add to Preferred Sources

What this button does

Get the right coverage answer the first time you search. Add Total CSR as a preferred source, and our expert-written coverage resources will show up higher in your search results.

When the producer who brings in the most revenue keeps costing you service staff, treat it as a conduct and leadership problem, not a personality quirk to work around. Confirm the cause, name the specific behavior, hold a direct conversation, agree on measurable changes, and follow up. Be ready to part ways if nothing changes. The dilemma is tough but not uncommon. A high-performing producer writes quality business and meets new business goals year after year, while a revolving door of account managers spins behind that person. The right fix depends on what is really pushing people out, so start there.

Confirm what is driving people out

Begin with evidence instead of hallway talk. Reread your notes from exit interviews and list who left, which desk each person supported, and the reasons given. If the same producer appears again and again, you have a pattern worth acting on. Then talk to the people who are still there. Hold stay conversations with the account managers who support that producer now, and ask what would make them leave. Staff who are actively disengaged rarely announce it, and turnover intent often shows up first as silence, slower follow-up, or a sudden interest in other teams.

Not every resignation traced to a producer comes from rudeness. Sometimes the cause is volume: the producer pushes a heavy administrative workload onto one desk, the workload distribution across the service team is uneven, and the result is staff burnout. Other times the cause is micromanagement, public criticism, or last-minute demands that ignore every deadline. In some agencies, the root cause is poor management, because nobody set clear expectations for how sales and service staff work together. Each cause calls for a different fix, and Total CSR has covered several ways to help employees avoid job burnout when workload is the main driver.

Measure the behavior against agency standards

Evaluate the behavior against what your agency considers good and prudent conduct between staff. Does the producer meet that standard? Ignoring the behavior has a long-term effect on the rest of the agency. Turnover may be the most pressing concern, but tolerance sends a message to every other employee that leadership condones the conduct. Left unaddressed, that message quickly erodes your organizational culture, and other agencies have shown how to use culture to fight turnover instead. If the conduct may involve harassment or discrimination, bring in your human resources lead or employment counsel before you do anything else. Sales results should not change the standard. A producer can sit in the highest performance quartile, or lead whatever productivity index your agency tracks, and still fail the conduct test. Hold top performers and bottom performers to the same rules, and say so with transparency. Account managers notice weak leadership fastest when a rule applies to everyone except the person with the biggest book.

Have the direct conversation

Have an open, honest conversation with the producer sooner rather than later. The problem may look obvious to you, but the producer may not see how far the behavior reaches or how many people it affects. Give feedback on specific behaviors that contributed to resignations, not on personality. "You are difficult" starts an argument. "Three account managers said you sent rush requests after 4:00 p.m. with missing information" is an illustrative example of a statement the producer can act on.

Use the meeting to agree on solutions, not only to describe the problem. Each solution should be actionable by the producer and measurable by the supervisor, and you need a process to follow up and monitor progress. Put the commitments in writing, set a review date, and ask the account manager how the collaboration is going before that review. The commitments below are hypothetical examples of what a written plan could include:

  • Submit complete new business information before asking for quotes.
  • Give the agreed lead time on requests that are not urgent.
  • Raise service complaints with the manager, not in front of the team.
  • Attend a monthly check-in with the account manager and supervisor.

Change the working setup where it helps

Review alternative setups that could lower the stress. Friction sometimes comes from sharing the same office all day. In that case, moving the producer to another location or having that person work from home may put enough distance between the two roles to reduce tension. Distance only helps when proximity is the real problem. If the trouble is unreasonable demands, the same demands will arrive by email. You can also change who supports the producer, split the book across a small service team, or route requests through a supervisor for a period.

Count what the revolving door costs

This problem isn't strictly about dollars and cents, but turnover costs the agency real time and money. Finding and hiring a new employee can take weeks, if not months. Onboarding and training then take more time before the new hire is ready to service a book of business. Replacement costs also include the hours managers and coworkers spend covering the open desk, and clients feel the gap. Total CSR's article on the high costs of turnover goes deeper on those expenses. Set them beside the producer's revenue when you weigh your options, because insurance agency turnover on the service side can quietly offset part of what that producer brings in.

Money alone rarely fixes it. A higher base salary, performance bonuses, and competitive compensation can improve employee satisfaction, but few people stay long in a job where they are treated badly. Look at the producer's side of the ledger too. A compensation structure built only on commission rates for new business rewards volume and nothing else, so consider whether part of the producer's pay or privileges should depend on how the producer works with the team. Total CSR's tips for producer management and compensation cover that subject. Leaders often tolerate bad behavior because they fear sales force turnover. Producer retention matters, but not at any price.

Prepare for the next case

Dealing with a producer who brings in revenue but damages relationships inside the agency is hard, and your agency will probably face it more than once. Prepare now. Build conduct into your selection system for new producers by asking how candidates worked with service staff in past roles. Make working with account managers part of producer development and of every new hire's training program. On the service side, employee retention strategies still apply: recognition for good work, a visible career path, and professional growth opportunities through ongoing professional development. Those steps support employee engagement and a better employee experience, so one difficult relationship is less likely to end in a resignation.

As you weigh the options, keep in mind three points the original version of this article, passed along by entrepreneur Gary Vaynerchuk, makes about why you might need to fire your most talented employee. First, toxic employees slow the organization down because people who worry about a coworker undermining them spend that time on that instead of their work. Second, emotional intelligence is becoming more important than technical skill. Third, internal culture sets the speed of the company. If the conversation, the written plan, and the changed setup do not change the behavior, letting the producer go may be the decision that protects the rest of the agency. For more insight on this topic, check out the full episode of The Independent Agent podcast.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should an agency fire a high-revenue producer who keeps driving staff away?

Sometimes, but only after the agency has done its part. First confirm the cause, give the producer specific examples, agree on measurable changes, and follow up on a set date. If the behavior continues after a fair chance to change, ending the relationship can be the right call. Review the producer agreement and talk with employment counsel before you act, because contract terms and state law affect how you should handle a separation.

How can a manager tell whether the producer is the real cause?

Look for a pattern across more than one departure. Compare the reasons people gave when they left, the desks they supported, and what current account managers say in private one-on-one meetings. If several people describe the same behavior from the same producer, the pattern is credible. If the reasons point to pay, workload, or a lack of training across the whole service team, the producer may be only part of a wider employee turnover problem.

What should the conversation with the producer cover?

Cover the specific behaviors, their effect on the team, and the changes you expect. Bring dated examples, explain that account managers have left because of them, and ask for the producer's view. Then agree on a short list of commitments the producer can act on and a supervisor can measure. Set a date to review progress, and say plainly what happens if the behavior does not change.

Can moving the producer or the account manager to another location solve the problem?

It can help when the friction comes from sharing space, such as interruptions, noise, or constant drop-in requests. A different office or a work-from-home arrangement may ease that kind of tension. A move will not fix disrespect or unreasonable demands, which follow people through email and phone calls. Treat a new setup as one tool alongside the direct conversation, not as a replacement for it.

How can an agency support the account managers who stay?

Tell them, without sharing confidential details, that leadership knows about the problem and is acting on it. Give each person a safe way to report new incidents, check in often, and balance the workload so nobody carries the difficult desk alone. Thank them for the work they are covering, and watch for signs of burnout such as missed deadlines or withdrawal. Staff are more likely to stay when they can see that conduct rules apply to everyone.